James Keene (Taron Egerton), the son of a Chicago police officer, was a gifted football player headed for a professional career. But a mistake he made landed him a 10-year prison sentence with no chance of parole. A prosecutor offers him a chance to redeem himself, but at great risk. A man named Larry Hall (Paul Walter Hauser) kidnapped and murdered a 15-year-old girl—just one of the 19 women he has killed in the past. Due to insufficient evidence, Hall may be released, and Keene's mission is to get Hall to confess to his murders from inside prison.