The Vanished First Love is a romantic comedy that begins with a misunderstanding between a high school boy and girl. Aoki Sota is a slightly clumsy boy who has a crush on his classmate Hashishita, the girl who sits next to him. One day, Aoki borrows an eraser from Hashishita and sees a heart drawn on it along with the name of their classmate Ida. However, Ida then sees the eraser and mistakes it for Aoki's, believing that Aoki has feelings for him...