One day, sixteen-year-old Danny (Avan Jogia) returns to his hometown, where he is about to begin his high school life. Back home, Danny reunites with his former playmates Jo (Maddie Hasson) and Lacey (Kylie Bunbury), who are now all grown up. A murder occurs in the town, a female student becomes the victim of the case, and Danny becomes the prime suspect, which is connected to Danny's dark past. At the age of eleven, young Danny was accused of murdering his aunt; with conclusive evidence, Danny was sent to juvenile detention, yet Danny has always insisted that what he did was right. Now, tragedy repeats itself, the shadows of the past linger, and what is the truth of the matter? Behind this incident, the true face of the small town gradually emerges.