Kimmy (Ellie Kemper) spent fifteen years living in a doomsday cult before being rescued by police and returned to society. Not only does this make Kimmy a media sensation, it also earns her the first real money of her life—a special government rescue fund. With only a few belongings, Kimmy heads to New York to start her new life. There she meets Titus (Tituss Burgess), a Black singer, and the two become fast friends. Kimmy's optimism and cheerfulness inspire the struggling Titus to keep pursuing his dreams, while Titus becomes Kimmy's only window into the modern world. Four other women were rescued alongside Kimmy, and they too set off on their own life paths.