The people living in Arcadia have encountered this strange phenomenon of the "return of the dead," and their lives have been completely changed ever since. An eight-year-old American boy (Landon Gimenez) wakes up alone in a rice paddy in a remote rural area of China; no one knows who he is, and no one knows how he got there. The boy, who calls himself Jacob, recalls that he is an American living in Arcadia, Missouri. Agent Martin Bellamy (Omar Epps) of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement brings Jacob back to America and takes him to Arcadia to verify his identity. Martin does not believe in so-called "mysterious returns" and suspects that illegal child trafficking is the real truth. The "home" Jacob describes is now occupied by a couple in their sixties—Henry Langston (Kurtwood Smith) and Lucille Langston (Frances Fisher). They did indeed have a son named Jacob, but their son tragically drowned in an accident thirty years ago. Although the aging Henry and Lucille look greatly changed, Jacob still remembers them as his biological parents. But how can that be? The child standing before them not only looks like Jacob as a little boy, but also knows every detail of his past life—unless he is Jacob himself, no one else could possibly know those things. Could this be an elaborately designed hoax?