Dana (Analeigh Tipton) leaves her hometown alone and comes to the bustling metropolis of New York, ready to embrace a bright new life. Dana is warm and cheerful, always giving off a positive, sunny impression—but no one knows that inside she is often filled with insecurity, feeling out of place in this city and among the people around her. Amy (Jade Catta-Preta) and her husband David (Nicolas Wright) are what everyone sees as a model couple. As Dana's former best friend, Amy opens her happy home to Dana as a temporary place to stay. Not only that, Amy also introduces David's younger brother Peter (Jake McDorman) to Dana, hoping to spark a romance. But clearly, Dana and Peter's first date is not as pleasant as imagined—it can even be called a disaster. Still, the confident Peter is convinced that the one at fault is definitely not him.